Red Hook · New York
Mark Iacono has made the pizzas at Lucali on Henry Street in Carroll Gardens himself since 2006, by hand, in a room with no menu. He is left out of the count below — it is his restaurant. The three who remain all sell pizza or pasta of their own a few miles away, and one of them says so out loud.
pitmaster-owner, Hometown Bar-B-Que & Red Hook Tavern
Best pizza in New York, Lucali.
Said on TopJaw · watch
owner, Best Pizza (Williamsburg)
Best pizza in New York, aside from mine: Lucali.
Said on TopJaw · watch
chef-owner, Cafe Spaghetti & Swoony's
See these on the map
GoodFinds collects what chefs, critics and people who'd know actually recommend — sourced, ranked and mapped. Get it on the App Store.
Published 2026-08-31 · updated 2026-09-01