owner, Lucali (Carroll Gardens) · 9 picks
Mark Iacono has made the pizzas at Lucali on Henry Street in Carroll Gardens himself since 2006, and has since added a Miami outpost and Baby Luc's, a slice shop down the block. TopJaw introduce him as the King of Pizza and then ask him where else to eat. His own restaurants are left out of the list below.
They're the only neighbourhood spot still allowed to roast on the premises.
Said on TopJaw · watch
order: coffee
I love their Sicilian square. It's like a hidden gem, not too many people know about it.
Said on TopJaw · watch
order: Sicilian square slice, biscotti
I love their Sicilian square, their biscotti. It's like a hidden gem, not too many people know about it.
Said on TopJaw · watch
order: Sicilian square slice, biscotti
See these on the map
GoodFinds collects what chefs, critics and people who'd know actually recommend — sourced, ranked and mapped. Get it on the App Store.
Published 2026-08-29